|
|
Post by MCForever on May 5, 2013 17:45:27 GMT 10
As Idol draws to a close for another season, what are your thoughts on Mariah as a judge.
Happy she did it? Wished she hadn't? Had good things to say? Not a good critic?
I personally think it's been great. Whilst the whole thing with Nicki has overshadowed Mariah's time (I think Nicki should have been the replacement for Mariah when and if she decided to leave) I think all in all it's been very positive.
Mariah has provided some great feedback and critiquing. Sure there were some weeks that seemed a little off, but as a whole I think she has been valuable.
I also believe that this exposure has proven more than anything Mariah's legacy and legend status amongst pretty much anyone and everyone.
|
|
|
|
Post by mcwbt on May 6, 2013 23:58:07 GMT 10
I'm glad she did it for one reason only - it gave her more publicity - especially for the younger generation who don't really know who she is. They are the ones she needs to win over these days. Personally, I think she could have been a bit better in her critiques. She doesn't have to be as out-there like Nicki but she doesn't necessarily have to be nice EVERY time when critiquing. That's what I think anyway! It's been good getting to see her every week though  |
|
Sam
Juicy Lamb
Posts: 396
|
Post by Sam on May 9, 2013 21:43:31 GMT 10
Well, firstly, that $18 million must be pretty nice! I feel that by being nice and giving constructive and more technical advice, the public will warm up to her more. It's also good that she's been the press a lot and is exposed to the youngins. I think she could had been more critical when critiquing though.
The whole Nicki thing.. *eye roll* Why would Nicki even try? I'm assuming it's jealousy. "Not everybody has that" was GOLD.
Loving Mariah's outfits! Hot, classy and mature!
Hoping that the rumours of a live performance are true! Looking forward to that and the video!
|
|
|
|
Post by tysonk on May 12, 2013 17:29:13 GMT 10
I think she was good and humble. She p***y footed around that dude that made it to top 5 when he shouldn't have. I loved how she babbled on and I did an 'inward cringe' lol. I liked her trying to articulate her view that time.
Personally I have found this round of judges really good with different opinions, comments and ideas. As much as I hate Nicki always digging at Mariah, and Mariah not able to ignore her (I don't think I could either lol) - they both added to the panel.
|
|
Sam
Juicy Lamb
Posts: 396
|
Post by Sam on May 17, 2013 22:03:42 GMT 10
Omg, that expression Mariah had on her face when Ryan said "the highest selling female artist of all time, she's sold over 200 million album, Mariah Carey performs live." I need a screencap of that. I've never seen a smile so genuine and radiant!
|
|
